La Scarpetta Opening Without Booze, Local Drunks Cranky
Posted at 04:50:31 PM in East Village restaurants, Restaurant gossip, Restaurant openingsby Justine Goodman
As reported by Grub Street
some weeks back, there's been activity inside the space formerly
occupied by East Village restaurant Uovo at 11th Street and Avenue B, soon to be La Scarpetta. I
knocked on the front door this afternoon and had a nice chat with the
executive chef, who confirmed that an Italian restaurant is in the
works and will be opening in some capacity very soon, but the exact
plans remain up in the air after the community board twice denied them
a liquor license. They are in the process of appealing to the state
liquor authority and have a lawyer who has "never lost a
case"--although lawyers throw that phrase around as much as their
clients do the phrase "I'm being framed," so make of it what you will.
In any event, the initial plan was to use their combined expertise in the kitchen--owner is former Bellavitae chef Pasquale Martinelli (as seen on "The Martha Stewart Show")--to open an authentic, full-service Italian restaurant, but that plan has stalled, since you can't very well have an authentic, sit-down Italian meal (or any other meal, for that matter) without booze. Both the owner and his chef are natives of Italy, where the latter says he "watched Pasquale grow up" before both moved to the U.S. and, as fate would have it, ran into each other on the streets of Brooklyn. At that time, the chef (whose name I have not-so-conspicuously forgotten, so let's just call him "Chef") was working in Miami, where he headed up various upscale Italian restaurants before relocating to New York and signing on to Martinelli's La Scarpetta project. For now, he says the restaurant may open as a more casual spot--think of it as expensive counter service without trays and with seating; not so much fine dining as just plain eating--at least for now, while their prodigal attorney works his magic.
While La Scarpetta may not have a problem competing with nearby Italian eatery 11 B
(that place is always empty--does anyone know how that stays open?), competing with neighboring Barbone may prove to be more difficult. Not to mention that Peter Hoffman's Back Forty just opened last week at Ave. B between 11th and 12th, and while that's not Italian, it does have a full bar.
Chef was so nice that I felt bad about La Scarpetta's predicament. I guess the sad truth is that the people who really have a vested interest in new liquor licenses being awarded are the very same people who are least likely to get their shit together and go to a community board hearing--the drunks.
For nightlife buzz, don't forget to check out our booze blog, Imbible.

They can not legally get a full license because they are within 200 feet of what the SLA has now determined a church. That is why Uovo decided to close. Uovo had a good lawyer too, but if you are within 200 feet of church. No go.
Posted by: matt | November 09, 2007 at 07:12 PM
rumor has it that Warren Pedesky is the lawyer on the case. He was the same lawyer that submitted Uovo's license and was there when the SLA made the community center a church. He could not get a license for Uovo so let's hope it is not the same lawyer.
Posted by: Matt | November 09, 2007 at 09:13 PM